Breakthrough research fraudulent, unpleasant science

‘Breakthrough’ research fraudulent, an unpleasant science

6:25 AM, 28th July 2014
Breakthrough research fraudulent, an unpleasant science
Scientists have been found to fabricate data and commit outright scientific fraud.

SINGAPORE: Scientists usually argue over the evidence for or against any important breakthrough. Sometimes announcements made in good faith do not stand up to detailed scrutiny, namely the replication of the research by other experts. On other occasions, scientists can be duped by the misconduct of their own colleagues prepared to cherry-pick favourable data to suit their conclusions, or, even worse, to fabricate data and commit outright scientific fraud – the most heinous crime in science.

One of the best examples of fraudulent research in recent years was the work on the cloning of human embryos by the South Korean researcher Hwang Woo-Suk of Seoul National University who announced in two scientific studies published in 2004 and 2005 that he had isolated human embryonic stem cells. It turned out that he had faked many of the results and that he had engaged in dubious ethical practices in obtaining the human eggs needed for the research. He was eventually charged and found guilty of embezzlement and bioethical violations.

Another case involving stem cells occurred in the past year with Haruko Obokata, a young cell biologist at the Riken research institute in Japan. Dr Obokata claimed, with her Japanese and American colleagues, to have created stem cells by bathing ordinary blood or skin cells in a weak acid solution.

She called the technique “stimulus-triggered acquisition of pluripotency” (STAP) and it promised to revolutionise medicine as it offered the hope of creating therapeutic stem cells from a patient’s own skin or blood with a simple, cheap technique that could be performed in any well-equipped lab. Unfortunately, it was shown that the scientific research paper contained errors and other scientists were unable to replicate the findings, leading to a complete retraction of the research. Dr Obokata, however, continues to believe that the technique works and is still trying to replicate here own findings.

Replication is of course at the heart of science. When chemists Stanley Pons and Martin Fleischmann announced in 1989 that they had achieved nuclear fusion at room temperatures – so-called “cold fusion” – physicists everywhere wanted to reproduce the findings. Nuclear fusion, which powers the Sun, was only thought to occur at extremely high temperatures. If it could occur at room temperatures it would open the door to cheap, unlimited and clean energy. It was too good to be true because it turned out not to be true. No-one has been able to demonstrate cold fusion as described by Pons and Fleischmann.

Sometimes a scientific announcement is made that chimes with a bigger philosophical significance. In 1996, for instance, NASA announced that it had found evidence of fossilised mini-microbes in a piece of a meteorite from Mars, which fell to Earth 13,000 years ago and was discovered in Antarctica in 1984. The clear implication was that life had existed on Mars and that we on Earth were “not alone” in the Universe. “If this discovery is confirmed, it will surely be one of the most stunning insights into our universe that science has ever uncovered,” said President Bill Clinton on the day of the announcement on 7 August 1996.

The trouble, once again, was that the discovery could not be confirmed by other researchers. It may have been a bad day for the idea of extra-terrestrial life, but it was a triumph for the scientific method.


© TimesOfIndia News



Your Comments (Up to 2000 characters)
Please respect our community and the integrity of its participants. WOC reserves the right to moderate and approve your comment.

Related News

New ultra-sensitive, low-cost system for detecting mercury in water

ADELAIDE, AUSTRALIA: Researchers at University of Adelaide have developed a new ultra-sensitive, low-cost and portable system for detecting mercury in ...

Read more
Rosemary, oregano shows anti-diabetic properties, finds study

WASHINGTON DC, US: The popular culinary herbs oregano and rosemary are packed with healthful compounds, and now lab tests show they could work in much ...

Read more
CB&I bags Versalis’ contract in North America

THE WOODLANDS, US: CB&I announced a cooperation agreement by which CB&I will market and provide engineering services for Versalis’ low d ...

Read more
FMC opens innovation centre in Shanghai, China

SHANGHAI, CHINA: FMC Corporation, a leading diversified chemical company, opened its Asia innovation centre in the Zhangjiang Hi-Tech Park in the Pudo ...

Read more
BASF invests €50 million in automotive coatings plant in China

SHANGHAI, CHINA: BASF Shanghai Coatings Co Ltd, inaugurated a new automotive coatings plant at the Shanghai Chemical Industry Park in Shanghai, China. ...

Read more
New approach for making organic zeolites

DELAWARE, US: Yushan Yan, Distinguished Professor, University of Delaware area of work focuses on zeolites, porous rock with a well-defined, crystalli ...

Read more uses cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. X